Is... added frequently. Recently, minicookies and cookie dough bites were added to the menu options as well. Crumbl is located at 2863 Taylor Rd. Tyler’s Bakery (7516 E. Main St.), which opened in 2011, is traditionally known for their amazing mouthwatering, stone oven-baked pizzas, but they also bake breads (sweet rustic, sourdough and challah), scones (assorted flavors), croissants (chocolate, cinnamon, and cheese danish), and cookies (chocolate chip and snickerdoodle) in house as well. In addition, pies and cheesecakes can be made to order. Another staple in the Reynoldsburg community is Anthony Thomas Chocolates at 7129 E. Main St. While the chocolates and candies are made at the local Columbus location, there are around 300 different types of confections including their popular Buckeyes, English Toffee and Pecan Dainties, which are sold at the Reynoldsburg location. If you’re looking for something without chocolate, they have non-chocolate options as well, which include buttery peanut brittle, cinnamon bears, nut mixes, and caramel corn. Coming soon to 7330 E. Main St. is rol Popp hand crafts a f dozens of specialty k at Sugar Rush, like Top right, in addition ery offers delicious center, a fan favorite, ight here in Columcakes at Sugar Rush butter and jelly, de crinkle cookies, roll commonly ndies, and brownies. yam native to the escribes as “having aste, which lends erts.” While she a brick-and-mortar with a few business sed interest in eir shops. atively new to the nally opened its first he cookies are made ition to the e chip, they offer such as peanut ke, cinnamon ge sandwich) that New flavors are Bruster’s Real Ice Cream. The original Bruster’s began in 1989 and now offers over 150 flavors in rotation including Blueberry Cobbler and Campfire S’mores during the summer. Bruster’s utilizes slow kettle processing to make their ice cream in house, and they also feature sundaes, cakes, pies, shakes and freezes. Sugar Rush Bakery began in 2018 by complete accident with a unique cake brought to an Independence Day celebration. By 2020, the first location opened on E. Broad Street and soon expanded to a larger location (in the Target Plaza) which now includes dine-in seating and a full bar serving alcohol. In addition to cakes, cookies, cupcakes, and Buckeyes, Sugar Rush offers cold brew coffee, specialty desserts and crazy shakes. Currently, there are 24 cookie and 24 cupcake flavors offered daily including Salted Caramel, Orange Creamsicle, and Tiramisu. But the crazy shakes, which feature a cookie and a cupcake on top, are the most popular menu item. Many of the sweet shops mentioned offer additional services to serve the community. Nothing Reynoldsburg Magazine • Fall/Winter, 2024 www.reynoldsburgmagazine.com 19 Bundt Cakes, Crumbl, Anthony Thomas, Bruster’s, and Sugar Rush all offer fundraising opportunities for local organizations. Crumbl, Bruster’s, and Sugar Rush offer catering, with Sugar Rush offering workshops as well. Whether you’re the cookie, pie or pure chocolate type, just remember, “Life is sweet, so sugarcoat it.” Mandy Young returns to Reynoldsburg Magazine as a contributing writer. She is an Ohio State University graduate in English and is also a member of the Reynoldsburg City Schools Board of Education.
20 Publizr Home